What a festival submission fee actually costs you in India
The number on the submission page is not the number that leaves your account. Here is where the difference goes, and how to work out your own real cost in about ten minutes.
The submission page says twenty-five dollars. You have a rough rupee figure in your head; you click pay, and you move on to the next festival on your list. A month later you look at the card statement, and the number is not the number you expected. It is rarely dramatic — a few hundred rupees here, a few hundred there — but across a submission season, it adds up to a fee you never agreed to and cannot see.
This is not a scandal. Nobody is hiding anything from you. It is simply that a price quoted in a foreign currency is an estimate until the money has actually left your account, and most filmmakers in India have never been shown where the difference goes. So here it is, line by line.
Four places the extra money goes:
1. The exchange rate you get is not the exchange rate you looked up
The rate you see when you search for the dollar rate is the interbank or mid-market rate. It is a reference number. It is not a rate anyone is offering you. When your card is used for a foreign-currency transaction, the card network converts at its own rate, which is set to sit slightly on the wrong side of the mid-market rate. You do not get to negotiate it and it is not itemised anywhere on your statement.
2. Your bank adds a cross-currency markup
Separately from the network's rate, most Indian banks charge a cross-currency or foreign-transaction markup on every international card payment. This is a real, named charge in your card's schedule of fees, and it varies a lot between issuers. Some travel-orientated cards charge nothing. Plenty of ordinary cards charge a few per cent. Look yours up once in the fee schedule PDF on your bank's site, as it applies to every international submission you will ever make.
3. GST is charged on that markup
The markup is a service fee, and GST applies to it. It is a small number in absolute terms. It is worth knowing about mainly because it is the point at which people stop being able to reconcile the statement against the price they were quoted.
4. You cannot claim any of it
If you are submitting through a registered company or LLP — a production house, a studio, or even a small one — a foreign submission fee usually arrives with no GST invoice you can use. The cost is real; the paperwork is not. For an individual filmmaker this changes nothing. For anyone running submissions as a business expense, it quietly makes every submission more expensive than its equivalent domestic cost.
In this example the real cost is about six per cent above the headline. Six per cent on one submission is not worth an afternoon of your attention. Six per cent across twenty submissions, on a short film budget you raised yourself, is a festival fee you did not get to spend on a festival.
Four places the extra money goes:
The costs that never appear on a statement
The arithmetic above is the visible part. The part filmmakers actually complain about is the rest of it.
- Declines on the last day. International card transactions from Indian issuers fail more often than domestic ones, and they fail for reasons nobody explains to you at the time. If it happens at 11pm on a deadline, you are choosing between a second card and a missed deadline.
- Refunds that lose money on the round trip. If a submission is refunded, the amount that comes back is converted again, at a rate set on the day of the refund. You can get back less than you paid without anyone having done anything wrong.
- No one to ask. A payment problem at midnight IST lands in a support queue that opens in a different timezone. The question is usually simple. The wait is not.
Budgeting in a currency you do not earn in. A festival plan built in dollars in June is a different plan in September. Most filmmakers absorb this quietly by dropping the last two festivals on the list.
The problem was never that submission fees are expensive. It is that you cannot find out what one costs until after you have paid it.
The costs that never appear on a statement
What to actually do about it
None of this requires you to change platforms, and most of it takes one evening.
- Find your card's cross-currency markup. One search on your bank's site. Write the number down. If you hold more than one card, use the cheaper one for every submission from now on.
- Reconcile one old submission. Take a fee you paid three months ago, find the rupee debit on your statement, and divide it by the dollar amount. That is your real, all-in exchange rate. Use it for every future estimate instead of the rate you find online.
- Build the festival plan in rupees. Convert every listed fee at your real rate, add it up, and decide the list against that total. Most people discover their list is about ten per cent bigger than they thought.
- Stop paying at the late deadline. The tier structure is the largest cost in this entire article and it is the only one fully inside your control. Early deadlines are frequently a third cheaper than late ones. Missing an early deadline costs more than every markup in the table above combined.
- Ask for an invoice. If you are submitting as a registered entity, ask before you pay, not after.
Where we stand
We are building The Film Sub because this arithmetic is the first thing an Indian filmmaker runs into and the last thing anyone explains. On our platform the fee is set and charged in rupees, it is paid by UPI, netbanking or card through an Indian gateway, and it comes with a GST invoice. There is no conversion step, so there is no conversion cost. That is the whole pitch, and you should hold us to it when we launch — if the number you are shown is ever not the number you are charged, tell us and we will publish the fix.
0 Comments
Be the first to share your thoughts.